Voice of America
19 Oct 2019, 04:35 GMT+10
WASHINGTON - Ukrainian legal experts say they are bemused by reports of American back-channel pressure to pursue an investigation of an energy company linked to the son of U.S. presidential candidate Joe Biden, pointing out the Trump administration could have easily achieved its goal through established legal channels.
The lawyers say there is a well-established tradition of cooperation between the two countries in criminal investigations, based on the provisions of a Mutual Legal Assistance Treaty (MLAT) signed by the two countries in 1998.
"This treaty extensively regulates all issues related to cooperation and communication between [signatory nations] on criminal investigations," said Ukrainian defense attorney Denys Bugay, a specialist in multijurisdictional proceedings.
"The treaty authorizes the U.S. Department of Justice and Ukraine's General Prosecutor Office ... or the agencies they delegate this responsibility to communicate. If one country thinks that it has or needs information important to criminal investigation, the communication should take place within the framework of this treaty and according to the instruments it provides."
Normal procedure
In a normal case where the United States seeks assistance in investigating an American citizen, he and other lawyers said, the U.S. Justice Department would open a case within its own jurisdiction and then ask Ukraine for help under the MLAT.
If the United States had followed these procedures in the case of the energy company Burisma and Biden's son, Hunter, there is little doubt that Ukrainian law enforcement authorities would have fully cooperated, the lawyers said.
That was the experience of American lawyers when they sought Ukrainian help in the successful money-laundering prosecution of Ukraine's former prime minister, Pavlo Lazarenko, according to Martha Boersch, a lead prosecutor on the case and currently an attorney with the California-based Boersch and Illovsky LLP law firm.
She described MLAT requests as a routine matter in which U.S. attorneys draft a request for mutual legal assistance and send it to the Office of International Affairs at the U.S. Department of Justice.
"They review it, they then forward that request to the central authority in Ukraine, which would be the General Prosecutor Office," she told VOA. "They would review it and decide if they can execute it themselves or send it to a local prosecutor. And that might mean getting documents sent or witnesses interviewed."
While localized legal or political considerations can affect the execution of MLAT requests, Boersch says she found that Ukrainian law enforcement agencies were typically transparent and responsive.
"The process was not difficult; they were forthcoming," she said. "We did not have any serious problems getting information from Ukraine."
Why go outside?
This has left the Ukrainian lawyers to puzzle over why Rudy Giuliani, President Donald Trump's personal lawyer, would have gone outside the normal channels to press Ukrainian authorities to open an investigation into Burisma and Hunter Biden, who served on the company's board.
Oleksiy Shevchuk, a managing partner with Kyiv-based Barrister LLC, believes Giuliani may have chosen the indirect route because the evidentiary threshold for justifying a probe in Ukraine is lower than it is in the United States.
Since the Soviet era, Shevchuk told VOA, even the loosest of pretexts could justify an investigation by Ukrainian prosecutors. But even then, he said, "it's hard to investigate something that has such little relation to Ukraine."
Kostiantyn Likarchuk, an experienced international litigator in the Kyiv office of the Kinstellar law firm, also pointed out that Burisma is an offshore-registered holding company and that there is no evidence of a crime committed in Ukraine by Hunter Biden.
"What could be the subject of the Ukrainian investigation? I don't think anybody understands it," he said.
However, Bugay, a specialist in multijurisdictional proceedings, said if the Ukraine prosecutor's office decides a crime took place within the country, it can indict anyone involved, regardless of the person's citizenship. "I have Ukrainian clients who were indicted in Belarus and Russia, and Russian citizens indicted in Ukraine," he said.
Original probe
Likarchuk said the original investigation of Burisma in 2012 - before Biden joined the board - concerned the suspected abuse of special subsoil land-use permits by the company's owner, who at the time was Ukraine's ecology minister. Therefore, the case and some others related to Burisma fell within Ukraine's legal jurisdiction, he said.
The U.S. has provided support for the structural reform of Ukraine's legal and law enforcement systems.
American officials were directly involved in the 2014 creation of the National Anti-Corruption Bureau of Ukraine (NABU), whose detectives underwent training sponsored by the U.S. Federal Bureau of Investigation.
The U.S. departments of State, Justice, Treasury and others all have representatives stationed in Ukraine.
Get a daily dose of Leeds Times news through our daily email, its complimentary and keeps you fully up to date with world and business news as well.
Publish news of your business, community or sports group, personnel appointments, major event and more by submitting a news release to Leeds Times.
More InformationDUBLIN, Ireland: Boots Ireland has admitted to breaking pricing laws during a Black Friday sale in 2023, leading to an investigation...
FRANKFURT, Germany: Volvo Cars, based in Sweden, is cutting 3,000 jobs to reduce costs as the automobile industry struggles with trade...
YOKOSUKA, Japan: Facing mounting losses and global restructuring, Japan's Nissan Motor Corp. is turning to its unique e-Power hybrid...
DUBLIN, Ireland: An Irish High Court judge has allowed the Irish Council for Civil Liberties (ICCL) to begin a class action-style lawsuit...
PARIS, France: French farmers brought traffic to a crawl around Paris and gathered outside the National Assembly on May 26, using their...
HANOI, Vietnam: Amid shifting global trade dynamics and growing concerns over U.S. tariffs, France and Vietnam have signed more than...
KATHMANDU, Nepal: Using xenon gas treatment and new technology is making climbing Mount Everest faster and better for the environment...
CAIRO, Egypt: Egypt has revealed three newly discovered tombs in the Dra Abu al-Naga necropolis in Luxor. These tombs, found by Egyptian...
TOKYO, Japan: As global inflation remains stubborn and growth prospects dim, central bankers from around the world gathered in Tokyo...
HONOLULU, Hawaii: A man from Oregon, Oliver Widger, has arrived in Hawaii after sailing across the ocean with his cat, Phoenix. He...
BUENOS AIRES, Argentina: The Archbishop of Buenos Aires, Jorge GarcĂa Cuerva, used a major religious event over the weekend to criticize...
CIUDAD JUAREZ, Mexico: In a first-of-its-kind judicial election in Mexico, more than 5,000 candidates are vying for over 840 federal...